How to Effectively Challenge and Overturn Insurance Claim Denials
By BMA Law Research Team
Direct Answer
When an insurance company denies a claim, the first step is to carefully review the denial notice for the specific reasons given. The denial must be in writing and should reference the policy provisions that were applied. If the denial includes a policy interpretation that's incorrect or misleading, dispute it by gathering all relevant documentation, medical records, receipts, correspondence, and expert opinions. Under the Federal Arbitration Act (9 U.S.C. SS1-16), many insurance policies contain arbitration clauses that can be used to resolve disputes outside of court. If the insurance company refuses to reconsider its decision after a proper appeal, you can request arbitration through the AAA/JAMS, which is often faster and less costly than litigation. You may also file a complaint with your state's insurance department, which is required for certain types of insurance, like health or auto.- Review the denial notice carefully for policy terms and rationale.
- Gather all supporting documentation before initiating dispute.
- Petition for arbitration if the insurer refuses to reverse the decision.
- File a complaint with your state insurance department if applicable.
- Understand that state law may require insurers to provide a specific reason for denial.
Why This Matters
Insurance claim denials not only affect financial stability but can have long-term impacts on access to care, housing, or employment. For example, a denied health claim could mean delayed treatment that worsens a condition, potentially leading to higher long-term costs. If you're filing for disability or auto insurance, a denial may impact your ability to continue receiving income or secure vehicle repairs. In the case of property insurance, especially after natural disasters, an incorrect denial could leave homeowners without the coverage they paid for and could delay necessary rebuilding efforts. Proper dispute procedures ensure that you are not denied benefits due to errors, misinterpretations, or fraud by the insurance company.How It Actually Works
- Document the denial and policy language. Write down the exact reason the claim was denied and reference all provisions of the policy that were cited.
- Collect evidence in support of your claim. Gather medical records, witness statements, photos, bills, and any other documentation that supports your side of the case.
- File an internal appeal within the insurer’s guidelines. Most policies provide a window, often 60 to 180 days, to file an internal review before further action is taken.
- Submit additional materials if allowed. If your appeal is denied or not responded to on time, submit a formal request for arbitration, usually in writing through the AAA/JAMS or similar dispute resolution provider.
- Engage an independent third-party arbitrator or mediator. The final process is usually held outside of court, with the arbitrator making a binding or non-binding decision depending on policy terms.
Common Mistakes
- Missing the deadline for internal appeals, most policies require a short window, often 30 to 90 days.
- Not providing necessary supporting documentation, such as medical records or expert testimony.
- Submitting a vague, unspecific appeal rather than precisely outlining how the insurer misapplied policy language.
- Ignoring state or federal requirements to provide a detailed denial notice, for instance, under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), a denial must explain the specific reasons and references.
- Submitting an appeal after the insurer has already made a final decision in the case, particularly when that decision is made outside a required time frame.
- Not using arbitration procedures when available in the policy or state law, this can eliminate alternative dispute resolution options.
Preparing a Dispute?
BMA prepares arbitration and mediation case packets. Flat $399, no hourly billing.
Learn MoreFrequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to appeal an insurance denial?
Appeal deadlines vary by insurer and policy, but most policies require an internal appeal within 60 to 180 days of the denial. Some states require insurers to allow up to 120 days, particularly for health claims. Always check your policy for specific time limits, and file as soon as you receive a notice of denial.
What should I do if the insurance company does not respond to my appeal?
If there is no response within the time allowed, typically 30 to 60 days, most policies allow you to file a formal appeal with the AAA/JAMS. This is particularly important in cases where the insurer has not provided a reason or has been unresponsive. You must follow the policy’s specific procedures for moving forward to arbitration.
Can I get legal help when disputing insurance claims?
While BMA Law does not offer legal representation, you can engage an attorney who specializes in insurance disputes, or use consumer advocacy organizations. However, for most situations, filing a dispute through arbitration, mediation, or internal appeal is sufficient. An attorney may be necessary in cases involving large sums, complex claims, or fraud.
How does insurance arbitration differ from court proceedings?
Arbitration is often less formal than court, with limited discovery and a final, binding decision. Unlike litigation, it’s usually faster and more private. Under the Federal Arbitration Act (9 U.S.C. SS1-16), arbitration clauses are enforceable unless you have formally opted out of them, and AAA/JAMS is a common provider for insurance claims.
Will my insurance premium increase if I dispute a claim?
For most policies, one dispute or even a successful challenge to a denial will not result in a premium increase. Some insurers may look at an excessive number of disputes over time, but it’s rare that a single claim denial is treated as a premium risk unless there’s evidence of fraud or misuse. Always review your policy to learn about your insurer's history with premium adjustments.