Home › Florida › Saint Augustine

Source: OSHA, DOL WHD, EPA ECHO, CFPB. Data covers most recent 5 years of federal enforcement records.

Federal Enforcement Profile: Saint Augustine

Over the past five years, Saint Augustine has exhibited a relatively moderate enforcement landscape, characterized by a total of 226 violations across various federal agencies and penalties summing to approximately $166,004. The enforcement heat score of 43 out of 10 indicates a manageable level of regulatory activity, suggesting that while violations do occur, they are not overwhelmingly prevalent. These figures provide insight into the types of disputes most likely encountered by residents and businesses within the city.

Overview of Enforcement Agencies and Violations

OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) reported only 3 violations during this period, resulting in $9,450 in penalties and notably, one fatality. This low volume suggests that workplace safety issues, while present, are not widespread but remain critical given the fatal incident. The Department of Labor (DOL) recorded 12 wage enforcement cases with back wages totaling $81,771 affecting 115 workers, indicating that wage-related disputes—particularly unpaid wages—are among the most common enforcement activities in Saint Augustine.

In contrast, EPA enforcement actions were nonexistent, highlighting a low incidence of environmental violations at the federal level within the city. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), however, received a notable number of complaints at the state level—over 1.6 million—though direct enforcement actions against specific local entities were not detailed, signaling perhaps broader consumer disputes thin local enforcement recordslude financial services, debt collection, or banking issues.

Major Violators and Dispute Types

Among the top violators listed, a local business. stand out in OSHA reports, with two violations each and penalties of $7,000 and $2,450, respectively. Their violations likely pertain to workplace safety, construction, or contracting disputes. The relatively low number of violations suggests that most businesses maintain compliance or that violations are often minor.

On the wage enforcement front, prominent cases involved local businesses such as Steve Chapman's All American Air Conditioning, La Catrina - 1 a local business, Inc., and Subway. These entities collectively faced over $82,000 in back wages, affecting over a hundred workers. This pattern underscores that wage disputes—particularly unpaid wages—are a significant source of federal enforcement activity in Saint Augustine, impacting labor rights and financial stability for affected employees.

Implications for Residents with Disputes

For residents and workers, the enforcement data indicates that wage-related disputes are the most prominent issues, whereas workplace safety violations, though less frequent, remain critical areas of concern. The absence of EPA enforcement actions suggests environmental violations are relatively rare or effectively managed locally. Nonetheless, the high volume of consumer complaints reported at the state level by the CFPB indicates that consumers in Saint Augustine may face disputes related to financial services, debt collection, or lending practices, which could, in turn, lead to further enforcement investigations if unresolved.

In summary, residents should be aware that while enforcement activity is moderate, issues concerning unpaid wages and workplace safety are tangible disputes they might encounter. Understanding these enforcement patterns can help residents recognize common dispute areas and advocate effectively when necessary.

Fight Your Dispute for $399

Professionally prepared arbitration case packets for Saint Augustine residents.

Start Your Case

Court litigation averages $14,000+ · 30-day money-back guarantee

Consumer Disputes

Business Disputes

Insurance Disputes

Real Estate Disputes

Family Disputes

Data Sources: OSHA federal inspection records, DOL Wage & Hour enforcement, EPA ECHO enforcement actions, CFPB consumer complaint database, IRS Statistics of Income, ACS Census data. Enforcement data covers the most recent 5 years.

Disclosure: BMA Law is a dispute documentation and arbitration preparation platform. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice or representation.